Contact Us: 781-705-6400

homeowner's exclusion - estate -planning - massachusetts - tax planning

Should the $250,000 Homeowner’s Exclusion Be Doubled?

Back in 1997, Congress changed the system for taxing capital gains on the sale of one’s home, getting rid of the former “carry over” basis approach to a $250,000 exclusion.

As a refresher on capital gain, it is the difference between the selling price and the property’s basis. The basis starts as what the homeowner paid for the property, but it may be increased by the cost of improvements. For instance, if you bought a house for $500,000 and spent $100,000 upgrading the kitchen, the new basis would be $600,000.

Carry-Over Basis

Under the old system, if you sold your house for $1 million, you wouldn’t have to pay any tax on the capital gain as long as you bought a new home within two years. The drawback was that the new house would have the same basis as your old house no matter what you paid for it. In our example, even if you bought the new place for $1.2 million, its basis would be $600,000. Then, if you sold it for, let’s say, $1.5 million, the capital gain would be $900,000 instead of $300,000.

The (Not So) New System

But that’s the old system. Since 1997 the rule has been that taxpayers can simply exclude $250,000 of the gain on the sale of their home. Married couples can exclude $500,000.

So, going back to our example of a house with a basis of $600,000 that sold for $1 million, it would have $400,000 of capital gain. If it’s owner were single, they could exclude $250,000 and pay taxes on the remaining $150,000 of gain. At a 20% rate, combining federal and Massachusetts taxes, the result would be tax liability of $30,000, or about 3% of the proceeds — not desirable, but not terrible. (The federal rate is graduated based on income, but most people pay 15%.) A married couple would not have tax liability since their $500,000 exclusion would exceed the $400,000 of gain.

Highly-Appreciated Property

But let’s look at another scenario. Let’s assume the couple, who we will call Mr. and Mrs. Wilson, bought the home many decades ago for $300,000 and due to the massive increase in housing values (or costs if you’re a prospective buyer) in eastern Massachusetts, they are able to sell it for $2 million. Let’s also assume that over the years the Wilson’s spent $200,000 on improvements bringing the basis up to $500,000.

The resulting capital gain in this scenario would be $1.5 million with $1 million taxable after the $500,000 exclusion, resulting in about $200,000 in taxes, or 10% of the proceeds. (In fact, they would pay a bit more given the new millionaire’s tax in Massachusetts.) This is a large enough “hit” that it could discourage the Wilsons from selling the house, especially if they understand that the step-up in basis would eliminate any tax on capital gains if their children were to sell the house after inheriting it. There would also be a partial step-up after the first spouse passes away, reducing the tax if the surviving spouse then sold the house.

The Effects of Inflation

But here’s the thing: If the $250,000 exclusion had been adjusted for inflation since 1997 it would equal a bit more than $500,000. If that had happened, the single buyer in our first example would be able to exclude all his gain. And Mr. and Mrs. Wilson would have only $500,000 of their gain subject to tax, cutting their tax in half to about $100,000.

Some argue that this would only be fair and more in line with what Congress intended in 1997 — to protect most homeowners from having to pay any tax on the sale of their homes. They also make the case that the prospect of capital gains is discouraging many older homeowners like Mr. and Mrs. Wilson from selling their homes thus contributing to a frozen housing market. The Wilson’s may be living in a large house they no longer need or want to maintain while there’s a young family out there who would like to move in but can’t because the house is not on the market. Reducing the Wilson’s tax liability may contribute in a small way to thawing the market.

Newsletter Sign Up

Contact Us

Contact Emily

Contact Abigail

Contact Richard

Contact Juliana

Contact Ilana

Contact Steven

Contact Sarah Henry

Contact Jason

Contact Sarah Hartline

Contact Laura

Contact Patricia

Contact Jeffrey

Contact Harry